Blondie I noticed another inconsistency in WT doctrine regarding how Elders are appointed in the congregations. Your reference quote for par 3 & 4 reads:
***w10 12/15 p.20par. 20***
The “gifts in men” also include members of Branch Committees, traveling overseers, and congregation elders—all of whom have been appointed by holy spirit. (Acts 20:28) …Granted, like the rest of us, they are imperfect. Still, we bless ourselves when we respond appreciatively to their loving shepherding.—Heb. 13:7, 17.
Yet, the “Bearing Thorough Witness” book on page 19 par 22 says this as to how Elders are appointed:
“…..To this day, responsible men are selected to serve as overseers in the congregations. The elders carefully consider the Scriptural qualifications required of such overseers, and they pray for the guidance of holy spirit. The congregation thus views such men as appointed by holy spirit. ……”
That earthly simple!
So the question is can the rank and file trust and have confidence that the elders are truly appointed by holy spirit? According to the wording of the BTW book, I think not. They are apparently selected by a popular vote by the elders much like when you join a mens’ club. If you’re liked you’re in and if you’re not liked you’re out. Holy spirit plays a very minor role in the selection process according to the BTW book.
This explains why the WTBTS is laden with many problems today!